TMBTMB
TMBTMB

Track, discover and find where to watch TV shows and movies.

Discover

  • Movies
  • TV Shows
  • Browse
  • Topics

Account

  • Watchlist
  • Watched
  • Ratings

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Content Policy

© 2026 Movie Browser. All rights reserved.

Data provided by TMDB

Home
Browse
Watchlist
backdrop
backdrop
logo
Two detectives so dumb, Sherlock Holmes would weep into his pipe.
TMDB
63
Rotten Tomatoes
47
Audience Score
47
Watch(US)

Do Detectives Think? (1927)

chaotic slapsticksilent era goldpure Laurel & Hardy

Overview

Comedy

An escaped convict is out to kill the judge who sentenced him. Two inept detectives are hired to guard the judge.

Flag of USUS
Content warning
short filmsilent filmblack and white

Standout Aspects

Practical Effects

Every gag is real physics, no CGI safety net.

Acting

Stan & Hardy's timing is mathematically perfect.

Best for:Solo: Perfect 19-minute lunch break chaos injection.·Friends: Watch their brains melt at actual 1920s stunt work.
Fred Guiol

Director

Fred Guiol

ReleasedNov 20, 1927
Runtime19m
StatusReleased

Vibe

Pacefast
Intensitymedium
Tonelight
Feellight
Hal Roach Studios

Top Cast

Stan Laurel

Stan Laurel

Ferdinand Finkleberry

Oliver Hardy

Oliver Hardy

Sherlock Pinkham

James Finlayson

James Finlayson

Judge Foozle

Viola Richard

Viola Richard

Mrs. Foozle

Noah Young

Noah Young

The Tipton Slasher

Frank Brownlee

Frank Brownlee

Detective agency boss

Chester A. Bachman

Chester A. Bachman

Officer

Will Stanton

Will Stanton

Killer's pal

Ask about Do Detectives Think?

Opens AI chat

Deep Dive

Trivia, insights & behind the scenes

Trivia

This was one of Laurel & Hardy's final silent shorts before talkies took over—Hal Roach kept them in two-reelers while other stars got features.

Insight

The title's sarcastic question became a meta-joke: critics at the time noted the detectives don't think at all, which IS the point. Silent comedy rewarded audience superiority.

YouTube

Outside the graveyard

Outside the graveyard

Gallery

Reviews

No ratings yet

Start the discussionBe the first to post — spoiler-safe
Rate & reviewBe the first to weigh in

Recommended

Shanghaied movie poster (1915)
5.9

Shanghaied

The Chaplin Revue movie poster (1959)
7.4

The Chaplin Revue

Big Business movie poster (1929)
6.6

Big Business

A Night in the Show movie poster (1915)
6.2

A Night in the Show

Dough and Dynamite movie poster (1914)
6.1

Dough and Dynamite

Towed in a Hole movie poster (1932)
7.0

Towed in a Hole

Oliver the Eighth movie poster (1934)
7.0

Oliver the Eighth

Beau Hunks movie poster (1931)
6.8

Beau Hunks

Mabel's Married Life movie poster (1914)
5.8

Mabel's Married Life

His New Profession movie poster (1914)
5.8

His New Profession

Below Zero movie poster (1930)
6.6

Below Zero

Our Wife movie poster (1931)
7.1

Our Wife

My Wife's Relations movie poster (1922)
6.2

My Wife's Relations

The Garage movie poster (1920)
6.1

The Garage

A Knight for a Day movie poster (1946)
6.6

A Knight for a Day

More Like This

Calling Scotland Yard: Falstaff's Fur Coat movie poster (1954)

Calling Scotland Yard: Falstaff's Fur Coat

Cutlass movie poster (2007)
6.8

Cutlass

Swell movie poster (2016)
6.3

Swell

OH, DEER movie poster (2025)
10.0

OH, DEER

A Bear in the Woods movie poster (2024)
7.0

A Bear in the Woods

Switch & Bitch movie poster (2015)

Switch & Bitch

My Life for Ireland movie poster (2016)
4.0

My Life for Ireland

Mom's Movie movie poster (2019)

Mom's Movie

Youth, love and fun movie poster (1964)

Youth, love and fun

Wife of the Future movie poster (2024)

Wife of the Future

Here Comes Kermit Williams movie poster (2024)

Here Comes Kermit Williams

Coffee and Cake movie poster (2016)

Coffee and Cake

Alirón 2: El descanso movie poster (2022)
2.8

Alirón 2: El descanso

Lazy Boy movie poster (2016)
6.0

Lazy Boy

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion — comments are spoiler-gated to your watch progress.

Discussion starters

View all comments →