TMBTMB
TMBTMB

Track, discover and find where to watch TV shows and movies.

Discover

  • Movies
  • TV Shows
  • Browse
  • Topics

Account

  • Watchlist
  • Watched
  • Ratings

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

© 2026 Movie Browser. All rights reserved.

Data provided by TMDB

Home
Browse
Watchlist
backdrop
backdrop
logo
The OG mistaken identity romp where a tiny man courts a large lady and chaos ensues.
TMDB
40

A Simple Mistake (1910)

Chaotic silent era energySlapstick before slapstick had rulesMarriage panic comedy

Overview

Comedy

Mr. Hallate is leaving for a trip and his loving wife is helping him to get his belongings out with him. At last everything is ready and she goes on the stoop and watches him get into the rig. Augustus Slip, who happens to pass at this moment, sees her and, like other men of small stature, becomes deeply enamored with the ponderous Mrs. Hallate. He goes and purchases a bouquet and, returning to the house, walks into the parlor and forces his attentions on Mrs. Hallate. She, however, will have none of him, and as he refuses to leave, flies for revenge to the maid in the kitchen. The maid happens to be entertaining her friend, Officer O'Brien, and Mrs. Hallate is indeed glad to see a limb of the law, and requests him to eject the eloquent Augustus. Meantime, Mr. Hallate has missed his train, and accordingly returns to his home. Augustus hearing him enter, hides behind a curtain, and when the officer enters Hallate is the only man in sight.

Flag of USUS
Content warning
MiscommunicationClass and statureMarital suspicion

Standout Aspects

Practical Effects

Real 1910 stoop-sitting and curtain-hiding technology.

Acting

Billy Quirk's desperate tiny-man physical comedy.

Best for:Solo: Quick 8-minute history lesson in early cinema chaos.·Background: Play it muted with your own ridiculous commentary.
T

Director

Theodore Wharton

ReleasedSep 24, 1910
Runtime8m
StatusReleased

Vibe

Pacefast
Intensitymedium
Tonelight
Feellight
Pathé Frères

Top Cast

Billy Quirk

Billy Quirk

Augustus Slip

Ask about A Simple Mistake

Opens AI chat

Deep Dive

Trivia, insights & behind the scenes

Cultural

This 1910 short reflects early cinema's obsession with 'marital suspicion' plots, where wives were always presumed guilty and chaos reigned. The 'ponderous' descriptor for Mrs. Hallate was considered hilarious body humor at the time.

Trivia

Director Theodore Wharton and star Billy Quirk were prolific in the silent era; Wharton later directed serials while Quirk became a reliable comic supporting player through the 1930s.

YouTube

A Simple Mistake (1910) L'Erreur du policeman [28 mm Pathé Kok version c.1912]

A Simple Mistake (1910) L'Erreur du policeman [28 mm Pathé Kok version c.1912]

Recommended

The Fireman movie poster (1916)
6.3

The Fireman

Held Up movie poster (1999)
5.8

Held Up

American Dreamer movie poster (2022)
5.9

American Dreamer

Mr. Bones movie poster (2001)
6.0

Mr. Bones

68 Kill movie poster (2017)
5.9

68 Kill

Why Worry? movie poster (1923)
6.5

Why Worry?

What's a Nice Girl Like You Doing in a Place Like This? movie poster (1963)
6.1

What's a Nice Girl Like You Doing in a Place Like This?

The Hangover Part III movie poster (2013)
6.2

The Hangover Part III

The Anniversary movie poster (1968)
6.6

The Anniversary

The Errand Boy movie poster (1961)
6.1

The Errand Boy

Duplex movie poster (2003)
6.1

Duplex

Much Ado About Nothing movie poster (2013)
6.8

Much Ado About Nothing

Nate Bargatze: The Tennessee Kid movie poster (2019)
7.4

Nate Bargatze: The Tennessee Kid

Bill Hicks: Relentless movie poster (1992)
7.5

Bill Hicks: Relentless

Fun with Dick and Jane movie poster (1977)
6.6

Fun with Dick and Jane