TMBTMB
TMBTMB

Track, discover and find where to watch TV shows and movies.

Discover

  • Movies
  • TV Shows
  • Browse
  • Topics

Account

  • Watchlist
  • Watched
  • Ratings

Legal

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Content Policy

© 2026 Movie Browser. All rights reserved.

Data provided by TMDB

Home
Browse
Watchlist
backdrop
backdrop
logo
A silent scandal where reputation burns faster than truth can run.
IMDb
67

You Can't Believe Everything (1918)

melodramacostume chaosmoral panic

Overview

Drama

Patricia Reynolds, the belle of the summer resort she is visiting with her friend, Amy Powellson, attracts the attention of Arthur Kirby, whom Amy loves. On an evening drive, Arthur tries to kiss Patricia , whereupon she leaps from the car and walks home. While Amy, disguised in Patricia 's clothing, accompanies Arthur to a roadhouse, Patricia , walking near the beach, sees her invalid friend, Jim Wheeler, jump into the ocean intending to kill himself. After rescuing him, Patricia persuades Jim to visit a specialist, but when she later is accused of spending the night with Arthur, she refuses to defend herself in order to conceal Jim's attempted suicide.

Flag of USUS
Content warning
lost film

Standout Aspects

Acting

Gloria Swanson's expressive face sells impossible sacrifice without dialogue.

Costume

The dress swap that launches a thousand misunderstandings.

Best for:Solo: Silent film devotees tracking Gloria Swanson's early stardom.·Date Night: Vintage cinephiles who appreciate dramatic irony and fan boats.
Heads up:Emotional: Suicide attempt and terminal illness themes handled with 1918 melodrama.
Jack Conway

Director

Jack Conway

ReleasedJun 23, 1918
Runtime50m
StatusReleased

Vibe

Pacesteady
Intensitymedium
Tonemixed
Feelheavy
Triangle Film Corporation

Top Cast

Gloria Swanson

Gloria Swanson

Patricia Reynolds

Darrell Foss

Darrell Foss

Arthur Kirby

Jack Richardson

Jack Richardson

Hasty Carson

Edward Peil Sr.

Edward Peil Sr.

Jim Wheeler

George Hernandez

George Hernandez

Henry Pettit

Iris Ashton

Iris Ashton

Amy Powellson

Claire McDowell

Claire McDowell

Grace Dardley

Kitty Bradbury

Kitty Bradbury

Mrs. Powellson

Ask about You Can't Believe Everything

Opens AI chat

Deep Dive

Trivia, insights & behind the scenes

Trivia

This is a LOST FILM—no known prints survive, so we're reconstructing from trade reviews and synopses like cinematic archaeologists.

Cultural

1918 audiences ate up 'ruined woman' narratives where female virtue was currency and silence was the only respectable defense.

Reviews

No ratings yet

Start the discussionBe the first to post — spoiler-safe
Rate & reviewBe the first to weigh in

Recommended

The Truth About Emanuel movie poster (2013)
6.0

The Truth About Emanuel

Won't Back Down movie poster (2012)
6.1

Won't Back Down

Return movie poster (2011)
6.4

Return

Eleanor the Great movie poster (2025)
6.9

Eleanor the Great

Reading Lolita in Tehran movie poster (2024)
7.3

Reading Lolita in Tehran

Sleep, My Love movie poster (1948)
6.3

Sleep, My Love

Lady Driver movie poster (2020)
6.4

Lady Driver

The Assault movie poster (2014)
6.7

The Assault

All Together Now movie poster (2020)
6.7

All Together Now

Bobby Jones: Stroke of Genius movie poster (2004)
5.9

Bobby Jones: Stroke of Genius

Head Full of Honey movie poster (2018)
6.4

Head Full of Honey

Blue Chips movie poster (1994)
6.1

Blue Chips

River of Grass movie poster (1995)
6.2

River of Grass

Woman of Straw movie poster (1964)
6.2

Woman of Straw

Little Lord Fauntleroy movie poster (1980)
7.3

Little Lord Fauntleroy

More Like This

Speed King movie poster (1923)
10.0

Speed King

The Venturers movie poster (1917)
8.0

The Venturers

A Blind Bargain movie poster (1922)
8.0

A Blind Bargain

The Case of Lena Smith movie poster (1929)
6.0

The Case of Lena Smith

The Hope movie poster (1920)
7.0

The Hope

The Sands of Time movie poster (1913)

The Sands of Time

The Prince of Broadway movie poster (1926)
7.0

The Prince of Broadway

With This Ring movie poster (1925)
10.0

With This Ring

Discussion

Sign in to join the discussion — comments are spoiler-gated to your watch progress.

Discussion starters

View all comments →